Honest verdict
5 supplements that are a waste of money
Last updated: 22 September 2026 · ~4 min read
Most supplements aren't scams — they're just sold far harder than the evidence justifies. Here are five that most people can skip, what they promise, and what to do with the money instead.
1. BCAAs (if you already eat enough protein)
The pitch: branched-chain amino acids for muscle growth and recovery. The reality: BCAAs are just three of the amino acids already in any complete protein. If you eat a reasonable amount of protein — or take whey or a decent plant protein — you're already getting them, and more besides. For most people, a separate BCAA tub is paying twice for the same thing.
Instead: hit your daily protein target from food or a single protein powder. Save the £25.
2. Testosterone "boosters"
The pitch: herbal blends (tribulus, fenugreek, "test matrix") that promise more testosterone, muscle and drive. The reality: the credible evidence that over-the-counter "test boosters" meaningfully raise testosterone in healthy men is thin to non-existent. Most of the effect people feel is the caffeine or placebo.
Instead: the things that actually move testosterone are unglamorous and free — sleep, resistance training, losing excess weight, and not being deficient in vitamin D or zinc. If you genuinely suspect low testosterone, that's a GP blood test, not a tub.
3. Detox & cleanse products
The pitch: teas, pills and "cleanses" that flush out toxins. The reality: you already own two excellent detox organs — your liver and kidneys. "Detox" products don't remove any named toxin; many just contain laxatives or diuretics, so the weight you "lose" is water and stool, and some carry real risks if overused.
Instead: water, fibre, vegetables, and less alcohol. That's the entire cleanse.
4. Fat burners & "metabolism boosters"
The pitch: capsules that melt fat or fire up your metabolism. The reality: the measurable effect is tiny at best, and most of what you feel is a big dose of caffeine — which you can get for pennies. Some contain aggressive stimulant blends that aren't worth the jitters or the blood-pressure risk.
Instead: a calorie deficit does the fat loss; a plain coffee does the energy. Neither needs a £30 tub with a flame on it.
5. Biotin for hair & nails (unless you're deficient)
The pitch: high-dose biotin for thicker hair and stronger nails. The reality: biotin deficiency is genuinely rare, and if you're not deficient, more biotin won't grow your hair — the "hair growth" evidence is mostly in people who were deficient to begin with. It can also skew some lab tests (including thyroid and heart tests), which is a real downside.
Instead: for most people, a balanced diet covers biotin. If your hair or nails are genuinely changing, that's worth a GP conversation, not a gummy.
The bottom line. None of these are evil — they're just sold on hope, not evidence. Before you buy anything, ask the two questions that actually matter: is the active ingredient dosed to a level that does anything, and is there real evidence it works for my goal? If the answer's no, keep your money.
That's exactly what Litmus is built to answer. Scan a label and we'll flag underdosing and filler for you, or use the finder to see honest evidence ratings on what's actually worth taking.
Scan a supplement you own →General information, not medical advice. If you're considering a supplement for a specific health concern, or you take medication, check with your GP or pharmacist first.